Is Manual Good For Off-Roading?

Manual transmissions are becoming less and less common in the cars that you can buy today. Many automotive enthusiasts are still massive fans of manual transmissions though, so this begs the question of whether or not manual transmissions are suited for off-roading.

Is manual good for off-roading? A manual transmission is a great option while offroading.  Its suitability depends entirely on the driver and his/her experience. There are both pros and cons to manual transmissions, but they can be great for off-roading and will outperform automatics in certain areas.

Many automotive purists still prefer manual transmissions over automatics in areas such as racing or off-roading due to the fact that it leaves them in complete control. You are always able to get your car into the right gear for what you are trying to do, and you don’t have to rely on your vehicle to make that choice for you. Apart from the ability to be in control, what other benefits do manual transmissions offer over automatics?

Is Manual Better For Off-Roading Compared To Automatic?

These days not many people know how to drive manual transmission vehicles anymore. In days gone by, manual transmissions provided better fuel economy, faster acceleration, longer life, and quicker shifts than automatic transmissions, but with current automatic transmissions this is no longer the case. Manual transmissions still shine in the eyes of automotive enthusiasts due to the fact that it gives them complete control over shifting. This creates a mind to metal connection with your vehicle that an automatic transmission vehicle cannot match.

So, when it comes down to it, is a manual better for off-roading? It’s hard to say if one is better than the other. There are pros and cons to each type of drivetrain. Especially when looking at new Jeep and Ford Bronco off-roading technology in automatic vehicles, manual transmissions have a lot to compete with! There still are areas where manual transmissions do shine though.

To consider whether a manual transmission is right for you, you will need to consider a few things. First of all, how comfortable are you driving a manual? Driving a manual off-road is quite a bit more challenging than driving a manual in town.

While looking at the obstacles in front of you, steering, accelerating, or braking, you also need to be manipulating the clutch and deciding which gear to be in. If you aren’t very comfortable driving a manual, then this can be very challenging and you will have to decide whether you want to take the time to get comfortable with it.

Secondly, you will also want to consider the types of off-roading that you intend to do. Where manual transmissions generally get outperformed is in low-speed ascents. If you are climbing hills at higher speeds, manual can be fantastic. Additionally, if you are driving through sand, snow, or mud manuals can give you the control to pick the gear you want to help you get through those obstacles. Taking into consideration the types of off-roading you will be doing, you can determine if a manual is a good fit for you or not.

The Pros And Cons Of Using A Manual While Off-Roading

So, what are the pros and cons of manual transmissions? First off, the biggest benefit of a manual transmission is the ability to be in control of what gear you are in. This can help you quite a bit when ascending or descending as you can choose which gear the vehicle stays in to control your speed better with engine braking.

An automatic could unexpectedly shift to another gear forcing you to have to react. Additionally, if you are driving somewhere slippery (snow, mud, or ice) you can choose any gear you want to be in. This can help you prevent from spinning the wheels excessively or even to help you really dig into the terrain to help you get through.

The second benefit of a manual transmission is that in general manual transmissions handle heat better. While abusing your transmission, a manual will tolerate the heat much better than an automatic. This means that your transmission will last you longer overall.

Additionally, there are cons to using a manual transmission vehicle for off roading. First off, in an automatic the car is constantly deciding which gear you need to be in. In a manual, you need to be analyzing that yourself and when necessary, pushing in the clutch and shifting the gear. It is just one more thing that you must constantly be aware of and ready to change at a moments notice if necessary whereas in an automatic, you can focus more on the obstacles in front of you and less on your vehicle.

Secondly, automatics will handle very low speed scenarios much better than manuals. This mostly comes into play when rock crawling. When you are rock crawling, you are frequently completely stopped, and may only inch forward a little bit at a time. In a manual this requires you to constantly be letting the clutch in and out and how smoothly you are able to do this can determine how successful you might be at rock crawling.

Tips For Off-Roading In A Manual

So, let’s say that you decided to go with a manual transmission as your vehicle’s drivetrain. What are some things that you can do to maximize your offroad performance? First off, get extremely comfortable and familiar with your vehicle. You want to be able to know where your engine rpms are without having to look at your tach. This will allow you to keep your eyes on the trail but know intuitively when you will need to shift up or down.

The second advantage of being familiar with driving your vehicle is that you can handle situations much better. You will be familiar with the clutch itself. You’ll know exactly how much you need to rev the engine and exactly how far you need to let out the clutch before you start engaging. Having these things be muscle memory will allow you to react at a moment’s notice on a trail while focusing on other things.

The last tip for off roading in a manual transmission is to take advantage of you being in control of the gears. Are you doing a higher speed ascent? Accelerate quickly in a higher gear to gain speed, and then downshift once you start the climb. Are you going down a descent and don’t want to rely so much on the brakes? Just shift into the gear that you want and let your engine do most of the work. If you are driving a manual transmission off-road, take advantage of what makes that type of vehicle special.

Are There Any Off-Roading Situations Where You Should Not Be Using A Manual Transmission?

So, if you do own a manual transmission off-roading rig, are there certain situations that you should avoid? In reality, you are fine to tackle just about any type of off-roading in a manual transmission. In certain conditions, your manual transmission will be at a disadvantage to automatic transmissions but that doesn’t mean that you can’t make it through those obstacles. Remember that initially, all vehicles were manual transmission.

One area where you may experience more trouble than normal with a manual transmission is rock crawling. Some find a manual transmission to be easier with this, but this is mostly for those who are very experienced. Here you are constantly going back and forth between being completely stopped and just inching forward.

This requires you to constantly be working the clutch in and out. It can become hard to get good low speed control in that situation and it will lay a beating on your clutch. That’s not to say that you can’t make it work, but rock crawling is easier in an automatic transmission.

Especially with newer technologies that are introduced into some of the newer off-roading rigs such as the new Ford Bronco, it becomes impossible to compete with using a manual transmission. The level of throttle control and brake control that you can have without even having to mess with the clutch makes it much easier to handle those really rough, low speed terrains in a manual transmission.

If you are wanting to get an off-roading vehicle with a manual transmission, don’t let this deter you too much though. Manual transmissions can be fantastic for snow, mud, sand, trail riding and much more. Manual transmissions have even made it through the toughest rock crawling trails out there. A good 4×4 will be able to make it through wherever you need it to, regardless of the type of drivetrain that it has. It is up to you to decide whether a manual transmission is a good fit for you or not.

Kyle Cannon

Kyle currently works as a mechanical engineer and graduated with a minor in automotive engineering. His passion for cars is his daily motivator and is constantly working on his projects such as restoring his 1966 Bronco, 1968 Firebird, or modifying his 2022 Bronco.

Recent Posts